Objection to Proposed Amendment 56

PROPOSED AMENDMENT 56 BRIEFING PAPER

PLEASE READ THIS PAPER AS IT AFFECTS YOUR HOME AND THE COMMUNITY YOU LIVE IN

You live in or own a property that is part of a “Special Character Area” (SCA) of the City of Busselton.  There are five Special Character Areas: Eagle Bay, Yallingup, Old Dunsborough and Quindalup and one small area in the town of Busselton.  They are called Special Character Areas because for over twenty years they have been recognised by the City of Busselton as having special and unique qualities that are worth protecting and preserving.  These qualities generally relate to the environmental, heritage or unique visual aspects of the areas.  These qualities have been preserved to date, by SCA policies adopted by the City and incorporated in its town planning scheme.  The SCA policies are required to be complied with by any person who wishes to build a house or develop a property in a specific SCA area.  They preserve such features as setbacks of houses from roads and the existing height limitations of buildings, so that as far as possible any new development fits in with the existing and unique character of the area.  These SCA policies have succeeded in preserving the special character of the areas for the last twenty years.

Three years ago, an over height house was approved by the city (in Yallingup) which did not comply with the SCA policy for that area.  A neighbour took action in the Supreme Court to take the City to task over the building of the house.  The Court decided that the approval of the house was contrary to the SCA planning policy and should not have been approved.  This case exposed the fact that the City had been allowing houses to be built in the special character areas even though they did not comply with the SCA policies because, it was argued, the City planners were entitled to use discretionary powers to allow some variations to the policies, if they considered that was appropriate.  The Supreme Court ruled that wording in the planning scheme did not allow planners to exercise discretionary decision making over certain key aspects of the SCA policies.

The Planning Department of the City has now proposed an amendment to the City’s Town Planning Scheme which would change the planning rules and allow City planners to continue to use discretionary powers to approve non-compliant development plans in “Special Character Areas”.  The effect of that would be to render the Special Character Area policies effectively unable to preserve the characteristics of the areas that should be preserved.

For this reason, we urge you to protect your Special Character Area by telling the City that you oppose this proposed Amendment 56.  We have persuaded the City Council to defer making a decision on the proposed Amendment, to allow us to inform you of the situation and give you the opportunity to voice your opinion.  We hope you will agree that the proposed Amendment should be stopped and we therefore ask you to spend a few minutes to tell the City Council that you oppose it.  If you are willing to do this it will send a powerful message to the Council, which we hope will help to persuade Councillors to reject the proposed Amendment.

You can send your opinion by signing and returning this page to us. To allow us to show the City that your opinion is valid and that you are a ratepayer and owner of a property, in a special character area, we would be grateful if you would add your name, address and signature (as below).  Of course if you disagree with us about this issue you can just ignore this letter.

I absolutely agree that this proposed Amendment 56 should be rejected by the Busselton City Council

Signature /s   ……………………………………………………………………………………………………

Name/s          ……………………………………………………………………………………………………

Address          …………………………………………………………………………………………………….

(Once downloaded, please sign and scan this page and then email the scan to:  reba@reba.org.au)

Please Read on

If you have the time we would encourage you to make a written (email) submission to Council. This will go to all Councillors and then make a very strong statement of community opposition to the proposed Amendment 56. If we don’t stop this proposed Amendment it will be the end to the current Special Area Character policies.

The following is suggested draft wording for your submission to Councillors. Please feel free to cut and paste sections into your email and modify as you see fit. Expressions of personal experiences are always valuable so if there is development that you consider has impacted on the amenity of your area and has breached the Special Character Area policy then consider expressing your views on this as well.

Send email to : councillors@busselton.wa.gov.au

Re: Objection to Proposed Amendment 56

State your name and that are a property owner and rate payer at “whatever your address is in the City of Busselton”.

I wish to urge council to decline to initiate the proposed Amendment 56 to the Town Planning Scheme as to do so would result in the following negative outcomes for the Special Character Areas identified in Schedule 4 of the Scheme, due to the following:

  • The Special Character Area (SCA) Policies and associated scheme provisions are designed to protect the very special coastal amenity and visual landscape values of those areas and also their contribution to the broader character and attractiveness of the region. The existing scheme controls are limited, fundamental and important to preserving these special attributes. To introduce discretion in respect of these specific scheme provisions will result in inconsistent decision making, undermining policy outcomes with detrimental impacts on the amenity of the areas, the resident communities and also local and tourist visitors to these special areas.
  • The community expects that the planning framework, including the scheme and SCA’s, is administered by the Council to provide consistency in decision making and confidence in the planning system for both the community and the development industry. This has been undermined by previous application of discretionary approvals and poor enforcement of the SCA scheme requirements and would be further weakened by this proposed Amendment.
  • To initiate the proposed Amendment for advertising will result in the final decision being removed from the Council to the Minister with the local communities then having little input to the final decision.

Any proposal to review the SCA related scheme provisions should be preceded by a broader review of the SCA policy framework that effectively engages with the potentially affected communities.  If appropriate or desirable changes are identified during the review process, then these should be considered in the drafting of the new Local Planning Scheme, currently in progress, and be subject to the associated public consultation requirements for the draft of the new scheme